Quote:
Originally Posted by Bobblehead
Well I'm not sure how they can rank these movies. Taken on its own, a rating is fine and gives a good representation of if a movie is any "good". But to then compare those ratings between different times and presumably different reviewers will not create a very accurate ranking.
It is like taking all the Presidents Cup winners of the last 30 years and then ranking them based on their regular season point total. It will give an interesting list, but the veracity of the list would be very much up for question.
Edit: But it does make for a good discussion starter.
|
I agree its not without its flaws but at least their is a methodology and its clear what this list is. most lists are just a seemingly random throw together based on the author's or a small group of people's opinions.
This is at least has some legitimate process behind it.
Not sure though why I'm defending it so much.