Quote:
Originally Posted by JiriHrdina
OK but even then the list is not out to lunch, the critics that are measured on the list are.
The list offers no opinion itself - its just a gathering of data.
|
The list sucks. This 'gathering of data', imo, has failed to provide an effective list. I understand its not the list's fault... though I'm not sure why that affects my thinking the list sucks. I'm not trying to make it feel bad, or hurt its feelings... just suggesting that it probably doesn't jive with most people's 'actual' top 10/100.
I'd also suggest that if you asked most critics individually, they would rate Star Wars over Children of Men. I assume this list is heavily biased towards contemporary movies... which is another reason it sucks. Just saying is all... mostly because I hated Children of Men, terrible movie!
