Quote:
Originally Posted by Agamemnon
I'm not misunderstanding it, I use Rotten Tomatoes all the time.
In this case, this list is out to lunch. I know how it was compiled, but that doesn't change it from being essentially (imo) bogus. Star Wars is better than Children of Men on any 'real' list that anyone could have. As far as I'm concerned this list is telling me that 'on average' carbon is better than gold. Fair enough... just not true.
|
OK but even then the list is not out to lunch, the critics that are measured on the list are.
The list offers no opinion itself - its just a gathering of data.