Quote:
Originally Posted by CMPunk
Shea Weber? Good player, but HOF worthy?
|
he's an interesting case. looking at him a little bit 2x first time all star and 2x second time all star- that's actually a bar that I would guess is mostly met by hall of famers (in isolation of course that is not enough but its a reflection of where he sat amongst his position over the years) and probably thats a fair reflection that there was a significant number of years where he was viewed amongst the top 3-5 D in the league
John Leclair has the most post season all star selections not in the Hall (and I don't think anyone really thinks he is one) at 5 and I'm not sure how many are at 4, one of my childhood favorites Rick Martin is at 4. but both Leclair and Martin played a less critical position and were bolstered by a HOF centerman