Quote:
Originally Posted by butterfly
|
Code:
Overall 2019 2018 2017 2016 2015 2014 2013
Bob McKenzie 100.2 101.2 102.7 101.6 100.4 100.3 100.2 94.9
Christopher Ralph 99.5 102.3 99.4 96.8
Craig Button 99.4 102.8 101.0 94.5 108.0 99.1 104.1 86.2
Eldon MacDonald 99.2 98.0 101.0 98.6
Future Considerations 98.6 97.6 100.9 90.0 105.8 99.4 101.1 95.7
HockeyProspect.com 98.2 99.2 102.2 99.5 99.8 96.6 92.1
McKeen's 97.2 97.5 103.1 90.4 97.4 101.9 99.4 90.9
Last Word on Sports 96.7 97.1 97.6 83.9 106.0 98.9 97.0
Ryan Kennedy 96.5 99.7 85.5 101.2 97.9 101.7 92.9
Ryan Pike 95.5 99.5 81.0 105.9
Scott Wheeler 95.2 93.5 97.0
Corey Pronman 95.1 100.6 89.7 83.7 97.6 98.2 101.5 94.7
ISS 94.3 97.9 97.0 83.0 101.4 97.3 90.0 93.8
With this weighting it's very clear that McKenzie matches the actual first picks of the draft most years. Congrats to cral12 who moves into second place. ISS still is terrible and Craig Button remains right near the top.
The 2016 draft provided lots of room to beat the actual GM results for any expert who had Juolevi, Puljujarvi and Alexander Nylander out of the top 10.
On the other end few of the experts did well in 2017 where teams picked Heiskanen/Makar/Pettersson at 3/4/5 and pretty much no rankings came close to matching that (McKenzie was close with those players at 3/4/7).