Calgarypuck Forums - The Unofficial Calgary Flames Fan Community - View Single Post

CaptainCrunch · 11-25-2023, 11:54 PM

No your not nuts, its a good list, mines a little different

Great!
Empire - great story, great dialogue, great characters, beautifully shot.
Rogue One - great story, great dialogue, great characters, beautifully shot, no Jedi game changing.
New Hope - great story, some dialogue issues, great characters, beautifully shot

Really good - couple “iffy” moments
Force Awakens - good story, good dialogue, good characters, beautifully shot, not a great set of villains.
Return of the Jedi - great story, great dialogue, great characters, beautifully shot, Ewoks was a questionable choice.

Flawed Had some stuff that was really immersion breaking
Solo - I liked it, ok story, surprisingly good dialogue, good characters, like Han and Lando, beautifully shot
Phantom Menace - underwhelming story, but Palpatines rise was great, awkward dialogue, Ewan, Liam and Ian were awesome, Natalie and Jake struggled, beautifully shot
Revenge of the Sith - rushed should have been two movies. Beautifully shot, Dialog was awkward throughout, Some good dialogue but not enough. Ewan and Ian were great, Haydan and Natalie were wooden, could have been so much better, but I still like the premise.

Bad
Last Jedi - Destroyed the trilogy, forced an attempt to recapture the fan base in the Rise of Skywalker, the story wasn't great, characters acting inconsistency, Made the villains putzes. Some nice shooting and effects. But overall just awful.
Rise of Skywalker - Palpatine was awful, the final fight was terrible, Rose had to miss the battle to do homework. Introduced Kerri Russells character who did nothing, Some really nice shots but it couldn't save the sheer insanity of the story.

Attack of the Clones - Could have been really good, but was over CGI'd. Hayden really struggled with the dialogue as did Natalie. The story really didn't go anywhere and it felt like an establishing story and nothing more. The final fight was underwhelming and was shot too much in close up. Yoda was ridiculous, it should have been a force powers battle instead.

11-25-2023, 11:54 PM	#2274
CaptainCrunch Norm! Join Date: Jun 2002 Exp:	No your not nuts, its a good list, mines a little different Great! Empire - great story, great dialogue, great characters, beautifully shot. Rogue One - great story, great dialogue, great characters, beautifully shot, no Jedi game changing. New Hope - great story, some dialogue issues, great characters, beautifully shot Really good - couple “iffy” moments Force Awakens - good story, good dialogue, good characters, beautifully shot, not a great set of villains. Return of the Jedi - great story, great dialogue, great characters, beautifully shot, Ewoks was a questionable choice. Flawed Had some stuff that was really immersion breaking Solo - I liked it, ok story, surprisingly good dialogue, good characters, like Han and Lando, beautifully shot Phantom Menace - underwhelming story, but Palpatines rise was great, awkward dialogue, Ewan, Liam and Ian were awesome, Natalie and Jake struggled, beautifully shot Revenge of the Sith - rushed should have been two movies. Beautifully shot, Dialog was awkward throughout, Some good dialogue but not enough. Ewan and Ian were great, Haydan and Natalie were wooden, could have been so much better, but I still like the premise. Bad Last Jedi - Destroyed the trilogy, forced an attempt to recapture the fan base in the Rise of Skywalker, the story wasn't great, characters acting inconsistency, Made the villains putzes. Some nice shooting and effects. But overall just awful. Rise of Skywalker - Palpatine was awful, the final fight was terrible, Rose had to miss the battle to do homework. Introduced Kerri Russells character who did nothing, Some really nice shots but it couldn't save the sheer insanity of the story. Attack of the Clones - Could have been really good, but was over CGI'd. Hayden really struggled with the dialogue as did Natalie. The story really didn't go anywhere and it felt like an establishing story and nothing more. The final fight was underwhelming and was shot too much in close up. Yoda was ridiculous, it should have been a force powers battle instead. __________________ My name is Ozymandias, King of Kings; Look on my Works, ye Mighty, and despair!