Quote:
Originally Posted by Beninho
Jews are indigenous to the land. Zionism was founded by secular Jews. You portraying the Jews as just believing it is their land because of religious scriptures is not true. Ethnic Jews descend from people who lived on the land several thousands of years before the creation of Islam. It’s ok to acknowledge both groups of people have a right to the land. Because people like you like to make conclusions about where Jews are from there are countless DNA studies done on Jews that verify what Jews have always claimed. Jews are from Israel.
The Jews accepted the 1947 partition plan which gave the Palestinians 70% of the land. Palestinians never even had a state to begin with so you would think 70% would have been fine, bare in mind Jordan got 73% of mandate Palestine. In reality the Jews got a sliver but that was still not accepted, like every deal presented to the Palestinians they rejected. Israel still then offered citizenship to all the Palestinians who stayed within Israel, hence why there are 2 million Palestinians with Israeli passports. So not exactly kicked off the land like you say. What do you think would have happened to the Jews if they lost any war? It would be October 7th for 365 days until every Jew was killed or expelled. Many of the founding citizens of Israel were Holocaust survivors or Jews fleeing pogroms in Arab countries fighting for their survival. Your statement is just devoid of any historical context, like most in this thread.
You can just say you don’t think Jews are entitled to a state and you would love to see what would happen to the Jews with a muslim majority country one state solution.
|
I was talking about the West Bank and Gaza, of.course the Jewish people should have their own country.