[Wastedyouth]

Originally Posted by CaptainCrunch

Ok, I've been thinking about the reasons for the appearance of Anakin in the World between worlds, and also about Ashoka and what seems like a life time of torture as she questions every decision she's made. The following is speculation. Remember I said earlier that I expect that Anakin is there to help Ashoka with her choices concerning the training of Sabine. Well, I think its much worse. In spoilers below though I don't think its spoilers just a fan theory gone mad.

Spoiler!

What are the big questions that haunt Ashoka


What if she hadn't left the Jedi Order


Would Vader have fallen if she had stayed by his side


Should Ashoka have abandoned training Sabine?


We know the World between Worlds can let you see all the possible outcomes, and though you can try to affect it, it doesn't work that way.


So what if Anakin is her guide. He can open portals to alternate time lines.


What if Ashoka hadn't left the order. What if she had stayed with Anakin. I doubt he would have taken her to Mustafar. But what if she had gone to fight with Kenobi against Grievous. What if they had both survived Order 66 there and pursued Anakin to Mustafar with Kenobi?


Lets say that the change of the time line is that Anakin kills Kenobi in a Maul like moment where Ashoka and Kenobi get separated. Now really enthralled by the power of the Dark Side, Anakin confronts his former Padawan and asks her to join him and she refuses, and Anakin strikes her down as well.


In the portal we now see a fully healthy and uber powerful Vader who serves Palpatine for a time until he learns everything from his master and in Sith tradition strikes down the Emperor and takes his place. Then Vader finds Luke who is unprotected by Kenobi who never has a chance to send Luke to Yoda. Vader takes Luke as his apprentice and we see an ever lasting Empire, because Ashoka doesn't leave Anakin or the Jedi Order.


This way Anakin teaches her that her decision was the right one, that no matter what he was going to fall, and by her not being there Kenobi survives and the Empire falls.


In the end Anakin tells her that she has to let go of her regret and indecision, that Sabine is going down the same road he is and Ashoka has to save her from the Dark Side.



Just a thought.

You put more thought into Star Wars than any writer has in any show ive seen.