View Single Post
Old 06-28-2023, 06:25 AM   #298
Fuzz
Franchise Player
 
Fuzz's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2015
Location: Pickle Jar Lake
Exp:
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by GreenLantern2814 View Post
My recollections of Calgary Catholic school religious studies, was that it was pretty tame.

It tried to contextualize the Bible a bit, and had very broad strokes “be good to people, blessed are the cheese makers, other religions have valid beliefs” sort of messages.

We’d have assemblies that were led by Father Bob, who’s nearly the most secular priest I’ve ever seen. He was fundraiser, not a hellraiser.

Did they discourage sex before marriage? Yes. Is that the worst thing to do to adolescents? Eh. I dunno. Having a kid when you’re still a fetus yourself seems like a bad idea. The birth control stuff is weird, you’d think they’d want to at least cover their bases. But when they tried to tell us masturbation was a sin, every boy in the room went “then send me to hell”

Nobody didn’t think evolution was real, or that dinosaurs were a hoax, or that the universe was a millennia younger than 10 billion.

But god is just as real. There’s a reason a version of god shows up everywhere, because something about that is true. And it doesn’t mean there’s a magic genie, but it does mean there are some universals to the human experience that transcend space and time. And religious stories do a better job of articulating those metaphors than just about anything.

Don’t let #######s take God away from you / God and its nature are unknowable, and you should always beware of people who claim to know unknowable things.

Your sense of right and wrong, your conscience, your soul - that’s all real. Only a fool would argue otherwise. Some grubby old men in Rome don’t know what happens to your soul when you die, but you know deep down whether or not you deserve to burn.

Because me, I think we get the afterlife we think we deserve. You know the sort of life you led, and if you did something that deserves an eternal punishment (like actually deserves it, not failure to abide by some Cherry-picked passage from a 2,000 year old copy of the Silmarillion), God or whatever you want to call the cosmic force that binds the universe together will see that you receive it.

But if you spent your life trying to do the right thing, trying to be honest and honourable, and trying to be brave even when you weren’t, when the time comes to stare death in the face, maybe you see your dogs again and have your grandparents remember you.

Maybe.
What "birth control stuff"? Do they tell you not to use it? And do you not see how telling adolescence they will go to hell and burn for it if they do something normal and natural? Presumably if they tell you masturbation is a sin, do they say the same about other same sex and alternate relationships? What do you think that does to people in class who may be confused about their sexuality, to be told it is evil and a sin? Why are my tax dollars paying for these "lessons"?

I'm not sure the point of the rest of your post and it's relevance.
Fuzz is offline   Reply With Quote
The Following User Says Thank You to Fuzz For This Useful Post: