Quote:
Originally Posted by Vinny01
I am not sure about that. Krebs was a 17th overall pick 4 years ago and has been decent but nothing suggests his value has increased. A legit top pairing, all-situations D, with 86pts in the last 2 years has helped Hanifin raise his profile. Size and skating is top notch as well.
An unproven 22 year old vs a proven 26 year old. The difference is not 3 spots in the draft in the teens. If this was going 5 to 2 or 8 to 5 then I see it but not 16 to 13. I think the better deal would be:
Krebs+13 for Hanifin+48
Or
Krebs+13+39+45 for Hanifin+16+48
|
I don't see Hanifin as a legit top pairing so that is where we would probably differ right off the bat.
I don't think either of your deals are off the mark either that is what I would push for if I were the Flames. I am trying to put some objectivity in it and thinking that from a Nashivlle perspective that the deal should make me a little angry not be such a clear win which I think your deals are.