To me it's pretty clearly Iginla, Lanny, MacInnis and Kiprusoff.
Iginla is an obvious lock and nothing needs to be said as to why.
MacInnis led the franchise to it's only cup with a Conn Smythe performance and Norris trophy season. He is the franchise leader in assists, and is by far the most productive defensemen in franchise history.
Kiprusoff is the franchise leader in all goaltending categories and was the best goaltender in the world at his peak.
Lanny while likely the least deserving due to his on ice impacts did captain the team to it's only cup victory, has the franchise record in goals in a season (66), and is truly the face and ambassador for the organization and city. He deserves to be there.
Fluery while a very good player holds no franchise records and his off ice antics speak for themselves. He should never represent this organization in any meaningful way.
|