Remember that offside on Lucic's goal that was called back... the player entering the zone dragged the puck along the blue line to avoid the defender and then crossed the line fully after Lucic entered. I think this is a good goal, I think that once it touches blue paint, then the threshold is reached, not the inside part of the line.
For a similar reason, I think that the McDavid's offside last night was onside, McDavid went to make a hockey play at the line to avoid the defender (O'Reilly) and push the puck to a place where he could grab it again avoiding O'Reilly... O'Reilly never gained control and only after both the puck and McDavid completely crossed the line does O'Reilly's stick get into a position in front of McDavid's stick and possession is in doubt. When skating with the puck, you're stick is not always in contact with the puck... but you still have control and possession, much like dribbling in basketball. O'Reilly never touched the puck until it crossed and McDavid put the puck to the exact place he wanted (showing control).
I think the call on the ice should stand unless there is an egregious call.... this 1 mm offside that is just too close for the linesman to call at real speed... that's onside. Remember why we brought this in, that offside that was missed where the player was offside by meters in the playoffs... that's what we are trying to prevent... not these plays above.
|