Quote:
Originally Posted by SebC
I would sacrifice simplicity, and heck I would even sacrifice some degree of objectivity, for a system that is more just in the sense of proportionality.
|
So basically less simple and more subjective? That's just asking for more confusion and chaos.
I'm at the opposite end. Simplify it as much as possible at the expense of proportionality in the interest of consistency.
Eg The disallowed goal rule where if it touches an attackers arm that leads to the goal. No room for subjectivity in interpreting whether accidental or not.
It's the subjectivity that results in loss of consistency.