[Sylvanfan]

If Monahan rebounded to score 22 goals and 50 points next year and post improved advanced and possession stats would we all be happy?

I would think so. But even that would be mediocre value for what he will be paid.

So even if you think he can rebound to that, what's a guy making 6.375 a year for one year worth to give you that?

I think you are lucky right now to garner a 5th for that. His career high is 34 goals and that happened 4 years ago. Even if healthy, odds are that his days of scoring 30 goals are probably behind him.