[iggy_oi]

Originally Posted by Cole436

Because as a survivor of abuse I understand how these episodes can warp your mind and make you unsure of not just your thoughts, but the reality around you.

Are you implying that another victim of abuse who has dealt with similar trauma couldn’t possibly disagree with your assessment? Because that’s kind of what it sounds like.

Again, I am not discounting that she could be dishonest with some of her statements.

Strongly disagree. You continually try to minimize it by arguing the inconsistencies in her story are a result of the abuse she’s suffered when there is no hard evidence to support her allegations.

I think you're villanizing people who have BPD.

Your opinion is noted, but I’m in no way trying to villanize people with BPD. Not every person with BPD does horrible things, but some are capable of doing things that are downright incomprehensible and malicious. You can’t ignore that just because they’re not all bad.

It's a very difficult mental disorder to live with but that does not mean people who have it are compulsive liars, manipulators, or monsters. Again, she was diagnosed by a therapist in his legal team so you should question lol the bias.

No one is saying they are all liars, manipulators or monsters. I’m not using the therapist’s diagnosis to justify what I’m saying anymore than you’re using her team’s therapists alternate diagnosis to support what you’re saying. Maybe she has ptsd, I don’t know, but she certainly has signs of BPD.

I think that section of the article is very clear in presenting facts. These allegations first came from her two yeas prior to even being married, and they were not brought to public light until years after their divorce. I think that fact there were numerous documented allegations during their relationship is enough smoke for me to believe there's some truth.

Again I think you’re underestimating what some people are capable of. Someone who’s willing to #### on a bed playing the long game on something like this isn’t out of what I would consider to be plausible. I’ve seen people do similar.

I think you should also look at the fact that Depp hired an entire legal team with the best money he could buy with his $150 million dollar fortune and Heard had a single lawyer whose legal fees racked up to her net worth even before the trial began.

What are you basing this statement on? Firstly, Amber heard had more than one lawyer. Secondly, I highly doubt you’ve got any realistic idea of how much her legal bill was compared to her net worth. If you’re going to make stuff up at least make it somewhat believable.