2022 1st* + 2023 5th + Tyler Pitlick + Emil Henieman for Tyler Toffoli pretty much equate to
2022 1st* + 2023 5th + nobody + nobody for Tyler Toffoli
and the 5th pretty much a nobody unless drafted by the Flames because only the Flames can turn a late draft into good player like Mangiapane
So it's
2022 1st* + nobody + nobody + nobody for Tyler Toffoli
I'd do this trade any day of the week.