Quote:
Originally Posted by CliffFletcher
They meet some of the same needs, but religions typically have some positive utility as well. They transmit useful social values, and can give people meaning, solace, and a sense of community. Conspiratorial thinking does not. It’s religion shorn of all wisdom and positive social value.
|
I think it's exactly that meaning-solace-community trifecta participation in a conspiracy community. I think it's reasonable to claim that religion provides these things in a way that is qualitatively different, but I don't think it's a coincidence that conspiracy-thinking has been rising as religious participation has been falling.
If I were to put my debate-coach hat on I think I could also make a compelling case that conspiratorial thinking does also transmit some useful social values, in particular critical examination of society. It
is a good idea not to trust authority, the media
should be questioned, industry does
not have the best interests of people at heart and this should be recognized, etc.
However, that would just be me arguing for the sake of thinking through my own ideas. While I'm largely of the opinion that religion is a net-negative for society, I absolutely recognize the major social values they promote are several orders of magnitude more valuable than anything that could be argued for conspiracy-thinking.