Quote:
Originally Posted by GreenLantern2814
I'm Holy Christing the notion that Brodie is anything less than a quality top-pairing defender.
He doesn't play here anymore, Tanev does. Great.
Brodie was awesome when he was here, and he's the exact same awesome player for the Leafs.
The way most Canuck fans feel about Tanev is the way you all should be feeling about Brodie, because my overall point really is that they're both high quality.
Tanev isn't "MUCH BETTER" than Brodie. He's arguably better at certain things, and demonstrably worse at others.
He's what he need him to be, and Brodie is what Toronto needs him to be.
It's fine.
|
This one is a pretty easy argument. It was always one or the other on the Flames.
If you do a poll on here who would you rather have, Brodie or Tanev, I'm thinking you would get a 80/20 split for Tanev.