Quote:
Originally Posted by GranteedEV
Dube is an inferior winger to Mangiapane.
He might be more valuable than Mangiapane as a center, but we'll never know that.
Dropping our best goalscorer the last two years and pinning our hopes to replace him on a guy the coach called, to some extend or another, "middling" is crazy.
|
But I doubt anyone can argue that monahan is as good as Eichel. That would be even crazy thing to claim
Also we did add Coleman. He’s similar to mangiapane as a 5 on 5 star who doesn’t get much pp time. Also he is great pk guy. Maybe if mangiapane gets moved in the deal dube does not need to replace mangiapane because Coleman will
Dube is also 2 years younger than mangiapane. Even mangiapane wasn’t at 23 was as good as his 25 year old version. Dube still has untapped potential.
I’d prefer dube in the deal over mangiapane but it would not stop me from making the deal if it had to be mangiapane