Quote:
Originally Posted by PepsiFree
Right, they're similar value because... as I said... you're guessing at the damage and the prognosis. Of course they're similar value... to you. My point was that it's silly to assume we know.
And it doesn't even make sense. You think that if Eichel is damaged goods, broken and on the decline with a limited career ahead of him... he has similar value to Seguin? I'd guess at that point he has almost no value at all.
|
What I said was "potentially damaged goods" and "has a career limiting injury/is likely declining" . Not sure whats left to be disputed there. The circumstances around Eichel clearly should lower his value. Not only does he need surgery, he's demanded a trade and also Is already signed to big money long term. All 3 of those factors lower value, we aren't talking about trading a peak performing player, we're discussing a player that might return to those levels, saying he's equal to 21 year old Seguin in value may be generous.