Quote:
Originally Posted by Textcritic
How many "defensive forwards" do you imagine could realistically win any of the Hart, Richard or Art Ross?
|
Good point. Defensive forwards also have it tough.
Although Crosby still seems to be relevant for Hart and Lindsey voting, despite not putting up big numbers anymore. I guess you could argue that's largely based on reputation or some other factors.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Textcritic
I agree with you, that in recent history the Norris Trophy has not been awarded accordingly, but the solution is not to create another award. The solution is for the selectors to enforce the criteria properly: the best defenseman is the one who excels at both ends of the ice.
|
I am skeptical of something like this being pulled off, so I guess that's where we differ.
GMs seem to be more aware of who are good defensive players actually are. They are often picked for national teams and get real minutes.
Perhaps if the GMs/coaches voted instead of the writers, we'd see some change.