Quote:
Originally Posted by browntrout
It's time to pay the piper, whether it's BT or a new GM the team needs to rebuild or trade for an star centre(highly unlikely) Take your lumps build through the draft. This core has proven they are not championship calibre, what's the point? I can't speak for everyone on this board, but I would be more excited about a rebuilding team then this continued medicority.
|
You don't necessarily need to go scorched earth to rebuild though. The key to being successful long term is knowing when to cash out on assets, and to not trade future pieces for short term pieces. That's the biggest mistake Treliving made on pieces like Hamonic, Smith, and Elliott.
Honestly the best course of action would be to do what a team like Boston did after the 14-15 season when they traded Lucic and some other pieces for draft picks.
Determine the people you want to keep as the long term problem, identify the pieces you think can be solutions longer term, and trade the rest for futures.
IMO I'd be keeping the following pieces.
Tkachuk
Lindholm
Mangiapane
Dube
Zary
Pelletier
These are the 6 forwards that you probably frame your top 9 around moving forward. Probably Lucic as part of the group just since they are going to be hard to move at their current contracts. Phillips and Ruzicka as guys on the farm that could maybe step in too longer term.
Tanev
Hanifin
Andersson
Valimaki
That gives you 4/6 dmen set for the future. Tanev probably would love being moved which is why he stays, plus he's been great this year.
Markstrom
Honestly if a team would want to trade for him I'd be willing to move him, but goalies are tough to move so I think he has to stay.
That means in the next 12 months they should be moving:
Gaudreau - 1X $6.75M
Monahan - 2 X $6.375M
Backlund - 3 x $5.35M
Ryan (UFA)
Bennett (RFA)
Leivo (UFA)
Giordano - 1 x $6.75M
Nesterov (UFA)
Rittich (UFA)
The only way you don't sell on all these guys if if you can somehow upgrade one of the forwards (Monahan, Tkachuk, Lindholm) and other pieces to turn them into Eichel. If not then do a real re-tool and trade the other pieces for Futures.
I still think the first deal I'd be making is Giordano to Toronto.
If we are retooling then give Gio the chance to go win a cup and re-unite with Brodie (man would it hurt to see those two win a cup as a pair in Toronto though).
Mark Giordano 50% Retained
Sam Bennett
for
Alex Kerfoot
Justin Holl
Nick Robertson
I liked the other deal that somebody else had yesterday too with Florida who can use Forward depth but a slight tweak.
Monahan
for
Anton Lundell
Then maybe for Gaudreau I think the Carolina Hurricanes would be the dark horse for his services and they try to go all-in for the next two seasons.
Gaudreau
for
Seth Jarvis
Jamieson Rees
2021 1st Round Pick
Imagine if you could add Lundell, Robertson, and Jarvis to the team's prospect pool....that should be the goal if we are moving Monahan, Gaudreau, and Gio.