Are you doing a trade analysis and/or draft analysis?
For trade you have to look at the value he got in return, not who they picked, otherwise you have to see who else was picked around that pick to see if its a "win".
GMs trade players for late picks and picks for late trades all the time, especially during trade deadline. In his case, they havent worked out for him much. But I'll call it a wash.
For me how did he do in big trades?
Picking up Hamilton was a good move. Even though it was a deep draft. Passing grade
Would NYR trade Fox for Lindholm or Hanifin? don't thinks so
Would Car trade Dougie for Lindholm or Hanifin? don't think so
Top it up losing Ferland in that trade too. Thats a middling grade at best if not a fail one.
Hamonic for that package was a big fail.
So 1 win, 1 tie, 1 loss. Par with this current group and his tenure, just average.
|