We seem to have this debate at least once a year. I completely agree if the deal is ‘close’ or involves a bunch of average players it shouldn’t be shot down. Like Pat said, the intention is not to let the new guy win every deal, the original intention around making all new deals a vote was to protect nooobs from being raked over the coals (the good old days.)
Everyone will have a different opinion on RFA vs UFA value but when it’s relatively close as is, just let it pass.
|