Quote:
Originally Posted by topfiverecords
Price GP 682 2.49GAA .917%
Andersen GP 369 2.63GAA .917%
Hellebuyck GP 270 2.64GAA .917%
Holtby GP 468 2.54GAA .916%
Murray GP 199 2.66GAA .914%
Markstrom GP 270 2.80GAA .911%
Koskinen GP 97 2.91GAA .909%
Demko GP 37 3.03GAA .906%
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by Oil Stain
Last three seasons would probably be a better comparison.
Holtby for instance has slid hard in his last couple of seasons. I doubt Washington dumps him if it weren't for that.
|
Career is very misleading - last three years is much better proxy but still doesn’t mean Edmonton’s goalies are any good .
Looking at the 7 "starters" over the last three seasons:
Hellebuyck: GP: 188 GSAA: 51.66 SvPCT: .919
Anderson: GP: 178 GSAA: 26.52, SvPCT: .915
Markstrom: GP: 163 GSAA: 15.56 SvPCT: .914
Koskinen: GP: 93 GSAA: 0.49, SvPCT: .911
Price: GP: 173 GSAA: -4.73, SvPCT: .910
Murray: GP: 137 GSAA: -5.01, SvPCT: .909
Holtby: GP: 161 GSAA: -23.45, SvPCT: .906
And the 7 "back ups" over the last three seasons:
Campbell: GP: 62 GSAA: 11.51, SvPCT: .917
Allen: GP: 129 GSAA: -4.04, SvPCT: .909
Rittich: GP: 114 GSAA: -8.36, SvPCT: .908
Smith: GP: 136 GSAA: -12.58, SvPCT: .907
Demko: GP: 37 GSAA: -5.19, SvPCT: .906
Brossoit: GP: 54 GSAA: -8.21, SvPCT: .905
Hogberg: GP: 28 GSAA: -8.29, SVPCT: .901
Winnipeg and Toronto have the best goaltending if you look over the last three seasons. Then I would say Calgary likely falls third after those teams.
Koskinen has okay numbers compared to the starter group, but problem is he's never actually been a starter. And his performance isn't that much better than Price/Holtby/Murray so you have to take into consideration how they are bonafide starters who have much better careers than Koskinen.
Plus I think the split in Edmonton will be pretty equal between Smith and Koskinen, so probably hurts there overall ranking too.