[Scroopy Noopers]

Originally Posted by Calgary4LIfe

Replying to Noopers - can't quote him for some reason.
I think you read my post wrong, or perhaps didn't quite understand the phrase "appears to be the real deal" and then qualified with "Elliott" and "Jim Carey".


To be clear, I have neither one of these goalies ranked ahead of the other. I do not state that one is the right answer, and the other is the wrong. In fact, I thought I was quite clear - NEITHER one of them seem like the right answer, though I can and do see the argument for each as being a decent argument in favour of acquiring them.


I, myself, feel that both of these goalies bring HUGE question marks, and I have zero confidence that either of these two are definitively the answer for Calgary. Add to that the perceived acquisition cost of either of them, and it does worry me considerably that Calgary is going to spend more assets on stop-gaps that won't really improve the team - just like Elliott, and just like Smith. I won't argue with anyone that these goalies are indeed worth the price - but at this junction, all I see with goalies right now are question marks.

Yeah my bad, I should work on my reading comprehension.