View Single Post
Old 08-22-2020, 02:16 PM   #80
GreenLantern2814
Franchise Player
 
GreenLantern2814's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2011
Exp:
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by bubbsy View Post
That's some crazy draft capital that translates to Lindholm, Hanafin, hamonic on this year's roster (that's frigin fugly).

By this summer that's 8 x 1st/2nd rounders spent (plus ferland, Adam fox), for a contribution of Lindholm and Hanafin.

Now, we approach a summer where it's universally agreed by fans, media, analysts that the core isn't good enough and needs to change, yet thd gm used up all this draft capital over the past 5 years on that?!?!

Treliving should have to essentially re-interview for retaining his job, and plan before he's given the authority to do anything this summer.

How CP gave this genius a higher gm rating than Darryl sutter is beyond me. Sutter blew a lot of draft capital, but those trades brought in big time players like kipper, tanguay, langkow, Simon, bouwmeester, cammalleri, jokinen.

I think we all wanted this somewhat unknown prodigy to be our guy, but there's too many warts in his process and results to not consider whether he should be the guy making the call for such a pivotal point for the franchise.
Kipper for a 2nd

576GP 305W 192L 68 OTL 2.46 .913 41 shutouts, 1 Vezina, 1 Jennings, First Team All Star, 2005-06.

Tanguay for Leopold, 2nd, conditional 2nd (2007)

Tour 1: 159 GP 40G 139A 179P
Tour 2: 183 GP 46G 99A 145P

Langkow for Gauthier and Saprykin

392 GP 123G 165A 288P over 6 years

Cammalleri for a 1st + 2nd, but recouped 1st + 2nd (2009) immediately by trading Tanguay to the Habs - Not counting his 2nd tour because Feaster acquired him.

81 GP 39G 43A 82P

Jokinen for a 1st, Lombardi, and Prust - counting all his numbers because Darryl brought him back after 26 games.

236 GP 59G 106A 165P

Bouwmeester for a 3rd + Leopold’s negotiation rights

279 GP 18G 79A 97P

Bourque for a 2nd

249 GP 88G 76A 164P

Huselius for Montador + Johner

216 GP 74G 108A 182P

Say what you will about any of those moves, they’ve produced a whole lot more than Treliving’s notable moves. And all these players were acquired between 2004-2009, with the exception of Kipper in November 2003.

Tre has Dougie, Lindholm and... who else has Brad acquired that has produced at a noteworthy level?

Doesn’t make sense.
GreenLantern2814 is offline   Reply With Quote
The Following 3 Users Say Thank You to GreenLantern2814 For This Useful Post: