Quote:
Originally Posted by Jeff Lebowski
With respect to the bolded, yes he absolutely does take the brunt of fan blame. Maybe it's because he's not an Iginla type (I think there are segments of the fan base that only like that type of player - big, bruising and can score).
Remember a few years back when Cammy was giving a post season interview and Millions suggested Johnny had to pack on weight? Cammy disagreed and said that isn't him. Just because a Cammy and St. Louis or even Mangiapane are similar height they have different frames. Meaning they are thicker players who can be strong or sturdy. Less observant fans want Johnny to do the same but he's got a slighter frame.
Cammy said that Johnny is effective because he's elusive. Cammy was able to always be pretty strong and could stand up against physicality.
To me Johnny has produced plenty in big games throughout his career but he's not going to be that put that team on my back guy like Iginla who was all power and toughness.
It's not Gaudreau's fault that he's kind of the only dynamic offensive guy who can consistently put up points by creating his own offense and creating for others.
I understand the frustration with the 5 v 5 results this playoffs but I don't agree that Johnny was unwilling or didn't try. What I see is a guy who always is trying to create - he doesn't shut himself down mentally (I think he's mentally strong player by how he keeps trying to attack, trying to make plays even when the game is going against him.
Gaudreau is a thread the needle type playmaker and dynamite off the rush. He totally transformed this team when he arrived on the scene. There are only a handful of people in the world that can do what he does on the ice. He needs help come playoff time but do you think a forecheck game is where he's going to excel?
I think CGY needs to look at how elite teams are not really forecheck teams in these playoffs. They gain the zone and attack in waves by backing the opponent off.
|
I think we agree..
I totally think Johnny is at his best when he is creating plays off the rush.
My point is Monahan just cruises into the slot flat footed all the time and Johnny comes down the wing with the puck looking for him.
It’s old hat and very predictable.
A center who can carry the puck in on his own with speed and has the ability to drive the net would open up so many more options for the line.
I like both players but think the days of them being on the same line together should come to an end.