I'm not as deeply in love with Tkachuk as most fans and here is why:
As yet not a playoff performer. Still early in his career, small sample size, but he just hasn't shown another gear.
Multiple concussions. I worry about him long-term. He had the bad back of the head to the ice after getting submarined a few seasons ago, Zadorov smashed him last years playoffs and now the head to head with Oleksiak. Not good at all. He could be damaged goods.
Contract status. Been mentioned above. Valid concern.
Is he captain material? Alternate, yes for sure, but I don't see him as a captain at this time. Too reckless, impetuous, and not respected enough throughout the league.
Personally I see Backlund as the logical choice to succeed Gio. He is home grown, heart and soul Flame, plays the right way, and often is our best most consistent player..
As for Tkachuk, I do wonder if there isn't a trade option there for the Flames. Depends, but I'd do Tkachuk to Ottawa for #3 overall. There's your shot at a 1C, right there.
|