I think the end of the day the only point that should stand regarding Gaudreau is , he is not the type of player you can anchor to and have him drag a team through the playoff muck. Strictly from a genetic stand point. Hes still all world skill and playmaking but in the playoff hockey format he just doesn't have physical attributes to get it done.
He can't be the primary driver on a run. Thats it. Unfortunately the Flames do not have the type of depth to not rely on him in a run. So on that point, the Flames have to dig deep call a spade a spade and get max value in trade. What that looks like is TBD.
As for Monahan, I think once he and Johnny are separated he will revert back to his norm but I think the duo system for those two was long stale.
Lindholm, I'm having a tough time reading all the disdain for him after this series. He is the bar that other forwards should aim and surpass. Best all around player on the roster, team leader in goal scoring this year, he did his job. The chemistry of the first line failed, thats it. Once he got to line with Backs he resurfaced and looked normal again.
Looks like he helped a lot last night too even in that horrific display the team gave us.
So, I think Gaudreau is really the one to go. Give Monny and Lindholm a few different options next year where they could play on different lines or have a new LW and play together who can help the forecheck.
I say trade Gio max retention to a contender. I think the return will be fair but I want my vision of a retool for the D corps to be all youth and one stable presence.
Tough to trade your Captain but I believe the time is now to make that move.
|