I was really high on Reinhart in the draft, but I don't want him on the Flames any longer. Gaudreau for Reinhart would be a massive downgrade IMO, so that pick better be their first... and even then I would want more.
If the biggest portion of the return is a current player, I want a player that is both quick and rugged with some skill. I don't want a player that is slow, non-physical and only 'decently' offensive. Reinhart seemed like he was going to be this cerebral 2-way centre that you could match up against the top lines and still produce. Now he is just a decent winger lacking footspeed. I would take him on the team, but I wouldn't pay much for him, especially Gaudreau.
|