Quote:
Originally Posted by Jiri Hrdina
Again, I don't know why people have to assume flawed thinking when someone has a different point of view. There are valid arguments for and against BT, well articulated and outlined by people on either side of the debate.
I'm 45 years old. I've followed the Flames since the mid 80s. Doesn't make my opinion more or less valid, but its an example of someone who has a strong impression of BT and someone who has followed the team closely for over 30 years.
When you say "anyone who voted him at 1 can no longer have their opinion on the matter taken seriously" it really stifles healthy debate.
|
Sorry. Brad at 1 is wrong.
What would you say if I said Robyn Regehr is the best player in franchise history? Would you debate it or consider it ridiculous? That's what Brad at 1 is to me.
I can see Brad at 2 arguments. I will agree that Sutter is not miles ahead of BT. However, BT at 1 is wrong wrong wrong. We won the cup in 89 under Fletcher and had several top 5 teams for years. People saying BT is better than Fletcher are saying 2+2=5.