[transplant99]

Originally Posted by DeluxeMoustache

Who, then, are “all time greats” on this club?

Brad McCrimmon is not an “all time great” by any means and he is basically going to be chosen #6

I liked guys like Macoun, Warrener, and Sarich. None were particularly flashy but these are solid guys who know how to win. Nobody would call them all time great though. Phaneuf could only turn one way, Bouw was a cream puff in the net and in the running for the green jacket, Lousy dropped off from his Buffalo / Winnipeg offensive levels, in his first of two short stints.

But yeah, I don’t see where the all time greats are hiding

Yeah...he really is. Heads and shoulders better than Brodie ever has been.