So my premise is to create the best all time lineup for the Flames. Then it can be compared to other all time rosters.
Rules are simple, players can play for multiple teams but only consider their performance with the club. eg: Martin St. Louis, could be on your team, but he'd be a tweener at best for CGY.
This is my attempt.
Gary Roberts -
Joe Nieuwendyk - Jarome Iginla
Matthew Tkachuk -
Doug Gilmour -
Theoren Fleury
Johnny Gaudreau -
Sean Monahan -
Jim Peplinski
Kent Nilsson -
Daymond Langkow -
Håkan Loob
Gary Suter -
Al MacInnis
Mark Giordano -
Phil Housley
Robyn Regehr -
Brad McCrimmon
I'd love to see some other line ups and talk about how they match against other teams all time rosters.