The best way to get them out of game management is to remove them from the ice surface. Added benefits that they don't clog up the corners and get in the way, and have the benefit of seeing all angles to make the correct calls.
I vehemently disagree with the "human element" of the game being stripped away by removing the refs from the ice surface- we're not watching the game for the human elements the refs bring, we're watching it for the human elements the players bring. I want to reffing to be spot on perfect and consistent. That will lead to a stronger product on the ice, and the subsequent bar talk and the like.
This is the structure I would argue for:
3 Permanent officials, 1 head and two others. They are sitting on the press level with a huge amount of cameras/ angles and tv screens, and a big buzzer button that will serve as the defacto whistle. also 2 (1 each) team reps to exist and advise/ ensure fairness. The ultimate calls will be the responsibility of the head ref.
2 Goon officials, released from the penalty boxes when the whistle sounds to break up any on-ice problems and keep the peace.
1 drone puck drop delivery system. That or the goon drops the puck and skates his ass back to the penalty box right away to get off the ice. I prefer the drone because it's cool.
This way we will get the right call every time, refs wont feel the need to manage the game because they will be removed from the action and can focus on doing their actual job by being impartial and judging each situation in the situation and not relational to past calls during the game or the scoresheet. Also encourages transparency for the fans and the clubs.
|