[Sylvanfan]

We will have to see what injuries Karlsson had this year. By the end of the playoffs he was struggling, but who knows what he was playing thru.

Has he had 1 or 2 achilles tears? I remember the Matt Cooke one that resulted in Melnyk's forensic investigation, but seem to think there might have been another one too.

For a player like him, that's a particularly tough injury given how he plays the game where he did use that elite skating to separate himself from others. He could probably still be a really good player, but three years ago he was arguably one of the top 5 players in the league with how how he could control the game on the back end. This past year he did look held back by injury.

So as it relates to this thread....it is all about what injuries has the player had, and how does it impact his game. For a guy like Hamonic...yeah, I'd tread a bit carefully going forward.