Quote:
Originally Posted by TheIronMaiden
If I were voting my major consideration would be to ask the question "where would this team be if player x was not on their roster".
McDavid- Oilers would be much worse, but they still suck anyways so not a huge difference
Crosby- This iteration of the penguins might not be a playoff team without him ( so altogether a good vote).
Kucherov - The Lightening would be a little worse off, but still a dominant team.
Mackinnon- The Avs would be a lottery team at worse, and miss the playoffs at best.
|
That is indeed the criteria. Unless you count jersey sales being valuable to a team.
But then again, where is St. Louis without Binnington? Where is Dallas without Bishop this year?