Its a very subjective question with no right or wrong answers.
I can only rank from players I've watched and followed, so basically 2000 and onward.
Iginla
Kiprusoff
.
.
Giordano
.
Regehr
Gaudreau
Monahan
.
.
Conroy
Backlund
.
Phaneuf
Gelinas
Anyone prior to 2000 I can't fairly rank, as I would be basing it solely off of stats and/or other's opinions.
|