Calgarypuck Forums - The Unofficial Calgary Flames Fan Community - View Single Post

devo22 · 02-01-2019, 10:19 AM

I'm heavily leaning towards SebC as well.

For starters, let's assume that a.) the Oilers didn't vote in a block on day 1 and b.) didn't vote for one of their own. I think both are reasonable assumptions, although I think b.) is a lot stronger than a.) because a loss of an Oiler on day 1 is a terrible start for them. But looking at those two things, that leaves the Scornfire voters as possible culprits: Hockeyguy15, SebC and myself (bizaro86 obviously being nightkilled already).

On day 2, both myself and Hockeyguy15 were firmly on the GGG train. SebC voted for him too, but unvoted when I voiced my concern about setting up hammer early. It's a convenient moment for him to jump off the train (443) and try to exonerate GGG (449) and shift blame somewhere else - which he does in 461, where he goes after crazy_eoj. But it gains no traction and GGG is lynched. Having voted for him before unvoting gives SebC a bit of town cred, but again he ends up without a vote on an Oiler. On day 3, he rides the crazy_eoj train again hard (595).

so at the end of the day, he is, I believe, the only player who neither ended up voting for one of the Oilers, but was firmly on the train for the one Flames fan that has been lynched. Not a good look. I know he's a good player who usually thinks a few steps ahead, but we're not playing 4D chess here and it's hard to ignore all those things.

02-01-2019, 10:19 AM	#709
devo22 Franchise Player Join Date: Jun 2011 Location: Austria, NOT Australia Exp:	I'm heavily leaning towards SebC as well. For starters, let's assume that a.) the Oilers didn't vote in a block on day 1 and b.) didn't vote for one of their own. I think both are reasonable assumptions, although I think b.) is a lot stronger than a.) because a loss of an Oiler on day 1 is a terrible start for them. But looking at those two things, that leaves the Scornfire voters as possible culprits: Hockeyguy15, SebC and myself (bizaro86 obviously being nightkilled already). On day 2, both myself and Hockeyguy15 were firmly on the GGG train. SebC voted for him too, but unvoted when I voiced my concern about setting up hammer early. It's a convenient moment for him to jump off the train (443) and try to exonerate GGG (449) and shift blame somewhere else - which he does in 461, where he goes after crazy_eoj. But it gains no traction and GGG is lynched. Having voted for him before unvoting gives SebC a bit of town cred, but again he ends up without a vote on an Oiler. On day 3, he rides the crazy_eoj train again hard (595). so at the end of the day, he is, I believe, the only player who neither ended up voting for one of the Oilers, but was firmly on the train for the one Flames fan that has been lynched. Not a good look. I know he's a good player who usually thinks a few steps ahead, but we're not playing 4D chess here and it's hard to ignore all those things.