Quote:
Originally Posted by dissentowner
I will leave my vote for now as WinnipegFan is not in any danger of being lynched, good to see him responding. If we can come to a consensus on who to lynch I will change my vote then. This game seems tougher because normally it is the same experienced players but with those new to the game it makes it harder to get a read. Are they playing the way they are because they are trying to learn or are they hiding behind the newbie card to protect their greasy asses? It is a pretty good bet at least one is doing exactly that.
|
So Diss starts banging the new player drum assuming without evidence that their is scum amoungst the new players. The only people who know the breakdown are scum
Quote:
Originally Posted by agulati
I'm more concerned about those who are either attacking without merit or piling on without merit.
.
|
New players do this not scum but sets up his later post on whatever new player does this
Quote:
Originally Posted by agulati
^Mrkajz, I have to say I agree on that statement. There has to be further reasoning to not Lynch/ban a new player other than them being simply "new".
For me personally,
Fuzz - His questions were too newbie. He could have asked them easily in the mafia forum, but he asked them here. He could have been playing us the whole time. So far I don't think so, and I think he is town.
WinnipegFan - I don't get the general vibe of him being a mafia, so leaning towards town for now. I voted for him, as stated previously, to get him to contribute. He did so and I removed my vote once he did.
Scorn - His posts come out a bit too defensive. I would think for a newbie, the other mafia might be coaching him to take it easy and not get too defensive, but since he has continued to be a bit aggressive, I'm leaning towards town again.
Bonded - I'm not sure about him yet. His vote just seems to be piling on to your vote which can be a newbie ploy but can also be a mafia ploy.
|
In response to MrKs post on how new players shouldn’t be exempt agulati does the reverse only evaluating new players and starts to pick which one he is going to lynch.
Quote:
Originally Posted by dissentowner
I have been going back through all the posts for a while now and I as of right now my suspicion is Bonded is an Oilers fan. Post #19 he is the first one to mention something from the PM posts, the Conn Smythe award. In that same post he suggests a random number generator before the game even gets started and we can get a read on things. At post #69 (giggety) he throws a vote on bizaro86. Either this is a deflection vote and bizaro and him are both Greasers or he is targeting a vet poster. Post #79 bizaro86 points out it is interesting he mentions the Conn Smythe. He adds in the fact about Bennett which got me a bit suspicious so I bring it up that it seems weird posters would mention this in post #81. We don't here from Bonded for a while until he pops back in post #193 with a weak reason to change his vote. Post #194 to unvote bizaro and post #195 vote for Agulati.
Post #234 he posts a I am a newbie post but overplays it with his "I am confused what the hammer is"
For my first vote I am betting Bonded is a poser and an actual Oiler fan. I am just not quite sure if bizaro is one as well.
|
Solid logic and fits the nartive that he built all day.
Quote:
Originally Posted by agulati
Agreed. As soon as I posted about newbies and asking questions in the main forum as opposed to mafia forum, if they are mafia, bonded comes up with a "newbie" question to play the part. That, along with no solid reasoning other than piling on to vote for me, and I am leaning towards bonded being a mafia now, and I am going to vote for him.
|
And Agulati try’s to get the wagon going with second quick vote in succession.