Quote:
Originally Posted by nobles_point
He didn’t trade Berra, Burke did.
I’m not being condescending I’m being factual. Cliff Fletcher is as valid a comparison for Treliving as Serge Savard. They are from a completely different era.
Glencross & Hudler were trade deadline deals so the teams acquiring them were looking for short term help. Reinhart & Seiloff were win/win trades as well. I don’t think the Predators even met the games played condition for the Flames to receive the pick for Reinhart. Seiloff lasted longer with the Senators than Chiasson did with the Flames.
If any of these trades are “wins” they’re still a long ways away from embarrassing the other team that made them to the point where they won’t deal with the Flames anymore.
|
WTF does a different era have to do with trading reps and being avoided because you fleeced someone?
You are really reaching here. I think you better check out games played for Seiloff - he played a game for the Sens. One game. How many did Chiasson play? And how much short term help were Glencross and Hudler? How good were the picks?
But leave Treliving aside, there have been recent "fleecings" by other gms who still seem to manage to find trading partners. Remember how no one dealt with Nill after he got Seguin and Peverly for a bunch of scrubs? And Spezza for Chiasson? How did Doug Wilson ever get a deal after stealing Thornton? How did Pile ever get a deal after Forsberg?