Smith should definitely be a F. In the past 15 years there have only been 2 goalies that have had worse than an .876 save percentage and played in at least 20 games. None in the last 10 years. He has been played at a historical level of terrible. There are no examples that I can find where there is a .054 difference in save percentage between two goalies on the same team. We could be watching history with Smith, so I think it is a well-deserved F at this point.
|