Quote:
Originally Posted by Mattman
Alright I want to count the amount of games that have cost us points this season, due to weak goaltending.
Oct 11th - St. Louis loss 5-3 Smith with 3 goals on 17 shots. Smith pulled.
Oct 19th - Nashville loss 5-3 4 goals on 24 shots. Flames were the hungrier team, but lost the goaltending battle.
Oct 25th - Pittsburgh loss 9-1 6 goals on 19 shots. Also given this was just a bad game collectively for the Flames. Some goals he couldn't save like the deflection, or Crosby's shot, but he was coughing up rebounds like something else.
Honourable mention: Nov 1st - Colorado 6-5 win. Smith let's in 4 goals on 14 shots. Smith let's in a couple softies.
Nov 7th - Anaheim 3-1 loss. 3 goals on 24 shots. Smith let's in a softy from Silfverberg.
Nov 15th - Montreal 3-2 loss Your chances of scoring a goal on Mike Smith seem to be significantly greater if you float a shot DIRECTLY at him. This shouldn't have been a game that the Flames lost. Smith let's in 3 on 22 shots faced. Our empty net faced 1 shot and 0 goals against.
This is just 6 games where I felt like Smith definitely had no control over the game and played worse than any of the goalies we have had in Calgary over the last 7 years.
6/13 starts for Mike Smith have resulted in games that cost us points so far.
I'm done with Smith. This is too well structured of a team to have it blown on lousey goaltending, and for that matter if this continues for even one more game, it's on the coaches and management.
|
Anaheim and Montreal for sure - there's no debate at all. I didn't think the team played well overall in the Nashville loss - I didn't think they were hungrier. I seem to recall the same against St. Louis, though him being pulled speaks a lot. I can't put Pittsburgh on any individual.
I tend to think there are actually more games they won in spite of his bad play than they've lost because of it. Which isn't a mark for him, it's a mark for the team.
I think we are all done with Smith as a starter. It's just that the options aren't great at the moment, and it seems to me that Rittich as number one for an extended period is all they can do.