[Textcritic]

Originally Posted by dammage79

Or, you could just accept the fact that people can form thoughts and opinions AND be right without data to form such a thought.

Why should I accept that your opinion on this matter is the right one?

I am happy to accept another opinion as correct when it has been sufficiently demonstrated as such. I am not satisfied by any of the arguments thus far for why Sigalet is obviously bad at his job.

Like you posted before, You don't understand how people came to form their conclusions on gully without backing it with hard proof and yet they were right.

Because not everyone is an intellectual and needs numbers and math to see things a certain way.

It's akin to being book smart vs. street smart or whatever you want to call it or defer to.

A couple of things, although this is starting to get far afield:

First, a number of posters were right about the fact that Guliutzan was not performing well as a coach, but that is different from being right about WHY.

Second, there is some truth to being "book smart" v. "street smart," and I do accept that someone can form viably true gut instincts about various situations. Is this one of them? Maybe. However, there comes a point in time in which "street smarts" require external validation. When one publicizes her or his opinion on a subject she or he is not absolved of the requirement to show the validity of the point regardless of the strength of conviction.

So, if this is your way of saying, "Trust me. I just know," then I am sorry, but no, I do not. I don't think it is untoward at all to expect those who harbour strong feelings to inspect them and to justify their convictions with useful evidence. I don't think I should have to apologize for not feeling as strongly as others when the evidence to support such feelings is fatuous.

I'm convinced that Sigalet is NOT a part of the solution despite not being a major part o the problem. But if you cannot help solve the problem, you need someone who can.

I am honestly interested to know how strongly you are convinced about this.