View Single Post
Old 10-27-2018, 10:45 PM   #4036
SeanCharles
First Line Centre
 
SeanCharles's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jul 2013
Exp:
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Bleeding Red View Post
Excuse me for missing the Bishop trade. I was going by his stat line. (My numbers come from HockeyBD & Capfriendly.)






Schneider was dealt at the 2013 draft for the #9 pick. CGY picked Monahan with the #6 in that draft. To make the trade for Schnieder Feaster would have had to give up the #6 pick - which he used for Monahan. (And since that trade Schneider has had only 2 seasons with more wins than losses.)



Most here would trade today's Bennet for a top goalie, but would they have traded the #4 pick at the time?



Ultimately the question is Are you OK with trading a lottery pick for top non-ufa goalie? If so, which ones do you think would be available at that price?

Holtby & Andersen are the only 2 that fit your criteria of 26-27 year-old elite goalie (though you don't define "elite").



Would MTL take a lottery pick for Price? TB interested in a lottery pick for Vasilevsky?



Goalies are a crapshoot
If we want to go back in time the most obvious is instead of Jankowski and Sieloff we draft Vasilevskiy.
SeanCharles is offline