Quote:
Originally Posted by TheScorpion
I'm not arguing that Brodie has been anything better than slightly-above-average in general, and that his (terrible) mistakes often seem to overshadow his otherwise steady play.
I'm arguing that Hanifin is much, much worse and should sit first.
|
If you think Brodie is slightly above average then we are watching a different player out there. He is awful. Has been for three years. Got a pass to start the season so he could go back to his proper side. Did not matter. He still sucks.
I don’t disagree that hanafin has also been bad. He has. As I said up thread, a significant downgrade from Hamilton. Through 9 games we’ve lost that trade.
Also, otherwise average (you say steady) can’t rescue terrible and costly decisions/play. You have to look at his whole game. And his whole game is bad. Not even close to top 4 d level play.