[flambers]

Originally Posted by CaramonLS

I guess we all have different conceptions of Franchise players.

Wells in my opinion simply isn't that special player you tie yourself down with. He has had 1 season, yes 1 with an OPS over .900, and only 2 seasons of 30+ HRs, and OBPs of .305, .359, .337, .320, .357. He still hits Right handers at a poor clip, with a career OPS of under 800 (.797) as well.

Those numbers, coupled with the fact we have a CF waiting in the wings (Rios) to replace him just scream red flags at me.

Think of it this way: Bobby Abreu is a free agent next season, in fact no one even wanted him except the yankees. He wont be getting the same kind of money he got from his last contract, which was around 13 million a season - BUT, he is also career a much better hitter than Wells. Better stolen bases, far better OBP, more doubles and close to as much power. Yet, no one will consider giving him that much money or that long of a term.

So think of it this way. Rios+Abreu or Rios+Wells. One combination hits better than the other, is cheaper and steals more bases. Oh, and with only a minimal downgrade in defense, if at all (Abreu has a gold glove too, you know).

Which one would you choose? They both fill the exact same holes as Rios/Wells would (CF/RF).

Without a question I would choose Wells and Rios. Wells is a Franchise type of player he is allot more than just a good hitter. Wells is a great Center Fielder who has won two Gold Gloves in a row.

However, If I had to bet I bet Wells turns down the offer. As I believe wells want to be become a UFA and sign with Texas next year.

Hopefully I am wrong.