Quote:
Originally Posted by Cecil Terwilliger
I agree with direwolf here. No one can say with any authority what Luke would have done. He’s a fictional character and given the reasoning they gave for his behaviour and his backstory made sense to me.
|
All characters are fictional though. You took issue with Batman vs Superman's characterization of Batman by having him kill. That Batman was less established then Luke and actually had more support in why he would have changed his tune considering the flashback insinuations. Here we had Luke have a vision that completely change the type of person he has been established in 3 movies?
It seemed like it was just a twist for a sake of a twist to keep up with the likes of Vader being Luke's father, Leia being Luke's sister or Kylo being Han/Leia's son. Having Kylo Ren turn evil because of Luke was suppose to be a talking point gasp moment but instead just turned flat.
But really, that was a rather minor problem with the whole story. Like why didn't they just tell Poe their plan? It's not like a secret you keep from your higher ups.