Quote:
Originally Posted by Enoch Root
Not much to argue about except the two new additions.
1. If you're going to include Czarnik, he should be higher IMO. I think he is a similar level to Andersson (same level of likelihood of NHL, but maybe a little less upside). I think he slots in after Dube.
2. Rychel. Having him 17th behind Joly suggests that he will almost certainly never see the NHL. Which is bizarre considering that, not only has he already played 41 games, but in all likelihood, he is still in Calgary on the 14 man roster when the music stops. I think he should probably slot in at #10, behind Gillies.
|
Valid points, but it depends on his methodology. Perhaps he sees Czarnik as a more likely NHL player than Mangiapane, Foo, but sees them as having more upside?
Phillips is also ranked a lot lower here, which to me seems like a bet against him making the NHL. Phillips to me is a guy who could be a high skill player who produces, or struggle in the AHL, such as huge boom/bust potential, but the kind of pick you make where he was selected.