Quote:
Originally Posted by PepsiFree
The only ask regarding racially-based privilege is to compare like for like situations.
“Check your privilege” does not mean “Hey poor white factory worker, recognise the privilege you have over the rich black executive!” That’s a straw man. It’s not meant to override any and all other factors. That argument is generally used by the wealthy to activate the lower class to fight against their own interests.
Regarding where it “breaks down,” you’re probably right, but you can also see why it breaks down when white, middle-to-late aged men (like CliffFletcher) argue against it. People who have very much benefited from white privilege more so than younger generations with the continued rise of equality, and yet refuse to even acknowledge it.
|
I disagree it’s a straw man when presented in media. Anyone in a position to shout that people need check their privilege through the media is priveledged in some manner beyond the average viewer. It is a lecture, this presents the wedge to be used to make people vote against self interest
The concept of checking priveledge works much better on a Campus, in a work place or in everyday reactions to event that occurs than as a preachy social agenda to advocate change.
I also agree that any white male in the top 10% of earners should very much consider the benefits they received as a result of birth when reacting to events or others actions.